If I accept only a portion of the Rambam's principles of faith, am I a Maimonidean? This is the Modern Orthodox world. They like Rav Hirsch's openness to secular studies, but they don't care to apply his filter. And they can't deal with Austritt either. They also no longer carry a conception of light unto the nations. That change came about because of the infiltration of Yeshivists like Hershel Schacter and because of their obsession with Zionism which sees the whole world as antisemites only because of criticism of the Israeli government. Much like the Yeshiva world, they appreciate his commentary on the Torah. They don't read his Collected Writings or his commentary on the Siddur or Tehillim. They are not Hirschians. They appreciate Hirsch. And that's fine but they don't get the benefit of his carefully cultivated derech. There are people who appreciate Chabad for not only its good deeds but even writings of the Baal HaTanya. Rabbi Soloveitchik was like that. But he wasn't a Chabadnik.
Pages
- Home
- Principles
- R' Hirsch's Writings
- Approbations
- Articles
- Links
- Audio and Video
- FAQ
- Yehadus Ashkenaz
- Contributions to MMA
- TIDE for Kiruv
- Chasidei Ashkenaz
- Teach Hebrew
- All People Matter
- About Us
- Yeshivas Frankfurt
- Judaism from Within
- Writings Online
- Rereading Rav Hirsch on Mitzvos and Gender
- D'var Yerushalayim (for BTs)
- Talmidei Chochamim
- On Zionism
- Rabbi Breuer Foundation
- Visiting Frankfurt
- torahimderecheretz.com
Monday, November 16, 2026
is half-way Hirshianism even that?
Rav Hirsch's anti-Zionism is so clear. As early as the 19 Letters we see it repeatedly. You cannot have a state without Torah. His prescience was remarkable considering that there was no Zionist movement as such in his lifetime. This isn't an isolated political opinion. It's central to his outlook. We build our lives around God and the Torah and its mitzvos are the way to do it. What's the point of a state that not only lacks that value but opposes it and the people who see life that way?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment